Carinallis are Farm Bureau’s Farm Family of the Year and will be honored at Love of the Land on July 11 

By Tim Tesconi  

In many ways, Sebastopol ranchers Domenic and Lynda Carinalli, along with their three daughters and seven grandchildren, are the perfect profile of today’s American farm family — dedicated stewards of the land who are pillars of the community and advocates for agriculture and their rural way- of-life. 

And like many farm families the Carinallis consider themselves the caretakers of their land and farming enterprises, working hard to position their holdings to pass on to the next generation and continue the family’s agricultural legacy.  That’s the way it has been for the last century that the Carinalli family has farmed in Sonoma County after leaving Italy for land and opportunity in America. 

The Carinallis have survived boom-and-busts in the milk market, droughts, economic downturns, the impacts of global wars and political turmoil to keep their land and livelihood.  Meanwhile, they are bracing for even more challenges ahead because fewer and fewer Sonoma County residents have ties to farming and little understanding of what it takes to put food on the table.  

“Sonoma County is a great county, it’s a nice place to live and farm and our family has done that for 100 years. But we will always have challenges as we work to keep agriculture viable and farmers on the land,” said Domenic, 83, a second-generation dairy farmer who also grows premium wine grapes as part of his diversified agricultural operation. 

 Domenic and Lynda Carinalli, longtime members and respected leaders of Sonoma County Farm Bureau, work together every day to manage their dairy and vineyards, overseeing 450 acres of owned and managed farmland in west Sonoma County. In addition to the home ranch and dairy on Gravenstein Highway, between Cotati and Sebastopol, they farm 93 acres of premium vineyards along Llano Road. Their grapes are sold to top-tier wineries with some of their fruit going into their own wine label, D & L Carinalli Vineyards. 

One of the big challenges the Carinalli family and other ranchers are confronting now is the effort by animal rights activists to severely curb livestock and poultry production in Sonoma County.  The activists are pushing for an ordinance that would ban most of the dairies and poultry operations in the county, part of a long-term campaign to eliminate meat, milk and eggs from the American diet.  

This ordinance not only threatens farms and ranches but an important source of food for consumers in the North Bay Foodshed and beyond. Sonoma County’s reputation as California’s premier wine and food region will vanish if this proposal is approved by voters in November. 

Most Americans consume meat, milk and eggs, said Lynda Carinalli, 77, a true working partner in the family farming business and a woman known for her vocal opinions when it comes to protecting and preserving agriculture and family farms. 

“Where is our food going to come from? The public needs to understand that the food on their plate comes from family farmers like us,” Lynda said.  

The Carinallis will join other ranchers and Sonoma County Farm Bureau to get the truth out about the good care that livestock and poultry receive on the family farms that have been part of Sonoma County’s rich agricultural history for nearly 200 years. 

The Carinalli family’s continued leadership, perseverance and longevity on the land are valued and recognized by Sonoma County Farm Bureau, the county’s largest and most influential agricultural organization. Farm Bureau has named the Carinallis the Farm Family of the Year for 2024.  

“Dominic and Lynda’s dedication of showing their dairy cattle at the Sonoma County Fair for over 20 years has helped to promote agriculture education to thousands of people,” said Doug Beretta, Sonoma County Farm Bureau President.

The Carinalli Family, along with other “Stewards of the Land” award recipients, will be honored at Farm Bureau’s Love of the Land celebration on July 11 at Richard’s Grove and Saralee’s Vineyard, the Windsor vineyard created by the late Richard and Saralee Kunde that is now part of Jackson Family Wines. 

The Carinall Family’s 100 years as multi-generational farmers is indeed a rarity for a family business. Studies show that only 30 percent of family businesses survive their founders and make it to the second generation. The statistics grow slimmer as family businesses pass into succeeding generations. 

Domenic and Lynda, who have been married for 56 years, have three grown daughters – Ann, Gina and Diane – and seven grandchildren.  The daughters all have careers off the ranch but help when and where they can. They are poised to one day take over the family’s farming business and perhaps even expand the family wine label, D & L Carinalli Vineyards. 

 Ann is a certified public accountant who lives in Windsor with her husband Paul. They have two grown children, Austin and Kendal.  Austin and Kelsey are expecting a child this spring. It will be Domenic and Lynda’s first great grandchild. 

Gina, an elementary school teacher, lives in Sebastopol with her husband Grant. They have five children, Matt (wife Genevive), Jake, Brooke, Victoria and Sydney.  

Diane and her husband Cory live in Chico and own a construction business. They have two children, Caden and Colby. In addition to helping with the construction business, Diane works for a farming company in Butte County. 

The Carinalli family farming legacy all began when Domenic’s parents Domenico Carinalli, an Italian immigrant, and Evelina Carinalli, who was a member of the Albertoni family and born in Sonoma County, started milking cows and raising chickens in 1924 on a ranch on Llano Road. In 1946 they bought the ranch on Gravenstein Highway where Domenic and Lynda make their home and operate their dairy. 

 The farmhouse is the command center for the Carinalli farming operations. While doing the books and record keeping, Lynda is on the phone dealing and dispatching to solve issues that crop up. One recent day it was a mountain lion that had mauled the ears of a calf at another ranch. 

“Every day is different and there’s always something happening,” Lynda said. In addition to the bookkeeping, she manages the family ‘s Laguna Valley Mitigation Bank for vernal pool preservation. Additionally, the Carinallis have a conservation easement with the Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation and Open Space District on their Llano Road property. 

“We believe in doing our part to protect agricultural land in Sonoma County,” Lynda said. 

Both Domenic and Lynda are involved in the community to meet the challenges that farmers face to stay on their land.  Domenic has been a director of Sonoma County Farm Bureau since 1968 and is the longest serving director in the history of the organization, which was founded in 1917. He served as Farm Bureau president in 1987-88. Additionally, he has served twice as the representative for Sonoma, Marin and Napa counties on the board of directors of the California Farm Bureau Federation in Sacramento.  

Domenic also served more than a half century as a director of Western United Dairymen, an industry organization, and was that group’s president. For many years he was a director of the California Milk Advisory Board and now serves on the boards of the Dairy Council of California and Guernsey Cattle Club. As a grape grower, he is an alternative board member of the Sonoma County Winegrape Commission. 

Domenic, a former volunteer firefighter, is a director of the Gold Ridge Fire District. Lynda and Domenic are both active parishioners at St. Sebastian’s Catholic Church in Sebastopol. Domenic is a member of the church’s Young Mens’ Institute.   

The Carinallis’ survival in the dairy industry is testament to their determination and resilience to keep producing milk in what is a very challenging business these days. They have cut their milking herd to 60 cows from the once 350 cows they milked in better times. They maintain a small herd of Guernseys that trace their bloodlines back to 1956 when Domenic purchased his first Guernsey calf as an FFA project at Analy High School. Today, the Carinallis have the last Guernsey herd in the North Bay and one of the few in California. 

Lynda loves her gentle Guernseys and takes pride in keeping their bloodlines going, handling all of the breeding and registrations. Each year, she brings her best cattle to the Sonoma County Fair, putting them on display for the public to see and enjoy. Last year, Domenic and Lynda brought 17 head to the fair and exhibited the grand champion Guernsey cow. 

The Carinalli vineyards, located in the Russian River Valley appellation, produce chardonnay, pinot noir and pinot grigio grapes. Domenic and Lynda planted their first grapes in 1996 to diversify their agricultural operations. It was a smart move as the dairy industry came under increasing economic pressure. 

“The wines grapes have been a real good experience for us. I grew up in the dairy business, became a dairy rancher and have had cows all of my life. But the grapes are something Lynda and I did our own. It’s been rewarding to grow grapes and produce wine that is recognized for its quality,” said Domenic. 

Domenic and Lynda are grateful to their friend Richard Mounts, a Dry Creek Valley grape grower, for encouraging them to plant vineyards on their land in West Sonoma County.  He advised them on the varietals to plant and assisted them in planting the vineyard. 

The Carinallis also are grateful to their 12 employees, some who have been on their payroll for more than 30 years. Some of the employees are the second and third generation of their family to work on the ranch. 

“We are thankful for our dedicated employees who work on the dairy and in the vineyard to make it a success,” said Lynda. “We all work together as a big family and we’ve been doing that for many years and generations.’ 

The Carinallis have no plans to retire from farming or their participation in the agricultural organizations they believe are vital to protecting the interests of farmers and ranchers. Then it will pass to their daughters. 

“We are going to keep it all going,” Domenic said.