By Pat Burns, President

I have been thinking about and dealing with the Potter Valley Project (PVP) for the last several years. With the help of many people, much more knowledgeable about the PVP than myself, I have what I believe to be a pretty good understanding of the project. Why it was originally created, what it did to and for our local communities, economy, agriculture and everyone in the area’s general way of life. 

Brief history of the PVP. It was started with the intention of using water to run turbines to create electricity for the City of Ukiah. Cape Horn Dam was built creating Van Arsdale Reservoir. That is the diversion point where water from the Eel River is diverted through a mile-long hand-dug tunnel that then goes through the hydroelectric plant in Potter Valley. The problem was that the power plant could not supply reliable year-round power due to insufficient flow in the Eel River in the drier months. To remedy the problem Scott’s Dam, which creates Lake Pillsbury, was built 12 miles upstream from Van Arsdale. This ensured that there would be sufficient flows to divert water year-round to power the hydro plant reliably. The water that was diverted through the tunnel and into the power plant then flowed out into the Eastern Fork of the Russian River through Potter Valley. That water then flows into Lake Mendocino then continues down the Russian River ultimately flowing into the Pacific Ocean at Jenner in Sonoma County. Water being the byproduct of the power plant became available to the people in Potter Valley and those downstream, making an invaluable resource available that helped build where we all live, farm, and thrive today. Without that water supply things would look and be a lot different around here. 

Maybe some or all of you who are reading this already know what I just wrote, but a short history lesson never hurts. If you don’t know about it, I encourage you to familiarize yourself and as many others as you can. I say this because we are facing the very real potential that the PVP is going to be demolished. To some that might not sound like a big deal but think again! Anyone who relies on or uses water will be affected by the loss of this project. That means all of us! The water that flows from the PVP is a significant portion of the water in the Russian River; although, it is a very insignificant portion of the Eel River- approximately 2-3%. Water keeps all of us going. We need it in our lives, every day, all of the time. Without it, we would have nothing. The flows from the PVP combined with the rains and runoff into reservoirs is what sustains life here.

In a time when clean energy is in demand, why would you want to demolish a hydroelectric power plant? So that 2-3% more water can flow into the Eel River? Why take down reservoirs? For fish passage, I get that, but with all the technology and abilities we have today can’t we build a fish ladder system that would work and keep the water flowing? Not to mention that invasive fish that feed on salmonids will still be in the system. Why don’t they work on eradicating them?  What about the lack of water available for wildfire fighting? We are told that the dams have outlived their expected lifespans and are seismically unstable. Here’s an idea, do some maintenance! Not many things last without maintaining them. The reasons and justifications that are being used to tell the story and or convince everyone why this system is planned for removal are, in my opinion, complete crap. Some group screams and some politician jumps at their demands. Another group screams and the water diversion allotment gets cut making the power plant less efficient and less economical. Like most things we all deal with regularly, this is political. 

The fact that we even have to fight to stop the demolition of this project really bothers me. It seems as though if others understood what this project really means to Sonoma, Mendocino, Lake, and Marin Counties maybe they wouldn’t be so fast at making deals for demolishing a system of reservoirs that has been in place for a hundred years. A system that ultimately was responsible for growth and continues to sustain agriculture and all the communities in our area. Again, I encourage you to learn more about this, tell the story, and encourage others to learn about it. All of us will be affected by the removal. 

On another note, I want to thank all the exhibitors, volunteers, staff, and sponsors who organized and participated in our Annual Sonoma County Ag Days! It is an important event for students, parents, and teachers to learn about agriculture, where their food and fiber come from, and to connect with local farmers, ranchers, and dairy producers.